Today, it's common knowledge that Earth revolves around the Sun. Many people credit Copernicus with introducing the heliocentric model—the idea that the Earth orbits the Sun. But more than two thousand years earlier, Aristarchus of Samos had already suggested it—and even attempted to calculate the sizes and distances of the Sun and Moon. Let that sink in: someone proposed this idea nearly two millennia before it gained acceptance. To appreciate just how bold and forward-thinking Aristarchus really was, we need to understand what others in his time believed.
Ancient Views of the Universe
In ancient Greece, understanding the universe wasn't just science; it intertwined deeply with philosophy, religion, and myth. Here are a few iconic figures from that era and their views on the universe.
Homer (around 8th century BC, possibly Ionia)
One of the earliest descriptions of the cosmos comes from Homer, the famous Greek poet who authored the Iliad and the Odyssey. Homer imagined Earth as a flat disk surrounded by the great river Oceanus, with the heavens forming a dome above it.
Thales (624–546 BC, Miletus)
Thales of Miletus, often regarded as the first Western philosopher, proposed a more scientific outlook. He believed Earth floated on water, explaining earthquakes as disturbances in this watery support. His ideas were revolutionary for his time, even though they lacked empirical evidence.
Pythagoras (c. 570–495 BC, born on Samos, later moved to Croton, southern Italy)
Famous today for his mathematical theorems, Pythagoras introduced significant ideas into astronomy. He proposed that Earth was spherical, a major step forward, but maintained it was fixed at the universe's center. For him, the cosmos was an orderly place ruled by mathematical harmony.
Xenophanes (c. 570–478 BC, born in Colophon, traveled widely in southern Italy and Sicily)
Xenophanes challenged traditional mythology, rejecting anthropomorphic gods. He imagined the universe as infinite and eternal, with Earth fixed firmly at its center. Though his astronomical details were limited, he influenced philosophical thinking deeply.
Heraclitus (c. 535–475 BC, Ephesus)
Heraclitus, from Ephesus, emphasized constant change and flux, governed by an organizing principle he called the "Logos." While he didn't directly contribute to detailed astronomical theory, his philosophy suggested a universe continually in motion and change.
Plato (428–348 BC, Athens)
Plato introduced a sophisticated cosmological model, placing Earth immobile at the center, surrounded by rotating crystalline spheres holding the Moon, Sun, planets, and stars. His geometrically perfect universe significantly influenced astronomy for centuries.
Aristotle (384–322 BC, Stagira and later Athens)
Aristotle, Plato's student, further developed the Earth-centered model. He proposed a finite universe composed of concentric spheres of a perfect and immutable material he called "aether," surrounding a stationary Earth. Aristotle's geocentric view dominated Western thought well into the Middle Ages.
Heraclides Ponticus (387–312 BC, Heraclea Pontica)
A student of Plato, Heraclides proposed that Earth rotates on its axis once every 24 hours, which was a significant step toward understanding the apparent motion of the stars. However, like others before Aristarchus, he still placed Earth at the center of the universe. No visual depictions of Heraclides have survived from antiquity.
Aristarchus Steps In: A Revolutionary Insight
Amid these varying theories emerged Aristarchus of Samos (c. 310–230 BC), who offered a groundbreaking perspective. Around 270 BC, Aristarchus boldly argued that the Sun, rather than Earth, occupied the center of the universe, with Earth and the planets orbiting around it. This heliocentric (Sun-centered) model was incredibly revolutionary for its time.
Aristarchus didn’t just suggest ideas; he provided mathematical methods to prove his theories. In his famous work, On the Sizes and Distances of the Sun and Moon, Aristarchus attempted to measure these celestial bodies using geometry and careful observation.
Aristarchus’ Calculations and Methodology
Aristarchus reasoned that during a half-moon, Earth, Moon, and Sun formed a right-angled triangle, with the Moon positioned at the right angle. By measuring the angle between the Moon and the Sun, Aristarchus calculated their relative distances through geometric relationships.
He formulated the following equation:
In this formula, θ (theta) represents the angle between the Sun and the Moon at half-moon. Aristarchus measured this angle as approximately 87 degrees. Modern measurements show this angle is closer to about 89.85 degrees—a small difference that significantly impacts calculations.
Due to this slight observational error, Aristarchus underestimated the Sun's distance from Earth. He concluded that the Sun was about 19 times further away from Earth than the Moon. We now know the actual distance ratio is approximately 400 times. Although Aristarchus' numbers weren't precise, his methodology was remarkably advanced for his era, laying critical groundwork for modern astronomy.
A Long Wait for Acceptance
Despite Aristarchus' compelling reasoning, his ideas did not gain traction. Aristotle’s geocentric model, later refined by Claudius Ptolemy, dominated for nearly two thousand years. Only during the Renaissance did Nicolaus Copernicus revive Aristarchus' heliocentric theory, finally proving that Aristarchus had been correct all along.
Aristarchus’ Lasting Legacy
Today, Aristarchus of Samos is recognized as one of the earliest true astronomers. His courage in questioning established beliefs, combined with his mathematical ingenuity, set a new direction for science. Though his ideas lay dormant for centuries, Aristarchus ultimately changed humanity's understanding of its place in the cosmos, anticipating by nearly two millennia discoveries that we now take for granted.
If you're inspired by Aristarchus' imagination and his ideas, check out our 👉 Aristarchus Collection for apparel featuring him and some of his diagrams.
Leave a comment